Dealing with Injuries to Children
byRobert O. Dawson
Professor of LawUniversity of
Texas School of Law
If you're in the horse business, you're probably also
in the kid business. A child (minor) is a person under
the age of 18. Children occupy a special place in the
eyes of the law.
Dealing with the Child. A child cannot enter into a
legally binding contract for the purchase of goods or
services unless the goods or services are regarded as
"necessaries."
For this reason, a release signed by a minor child is
not binding on the child. It is voidable and the child
can disavow it simply by bringing a lawsuit after being
injured. In other words, its not worth the paper it is
written on as a release. Smoky v. McCray, 396 S.E.2d 794
(Ga.App.1990)(release signed by fourteen year old not
valid as a release).
Just because the release is not valid as a release
does not mean that you shouldn't use one when dealing
with a child. The warnings about the nature of the horse
and the risks of horseback riding that ordinarily
accompany the release can become important even when the
student is a child. A child who is at least seven years
of age is capable of being negligent. Therefore, if he
is injured in an accident that was partially his fault
(considering his age and experience with horses), he may
not be able to sue successfully or, at least, the award
may be reduced by the extent of his negligence compared
to that of the stables. Willenbring v. Borkenhagen, 139
N.W.2d 53 (Wis.1966)(seventeen year-old was 40 percent
negligent in trail ride accident).
Therefore, it is important that an employee explain
to the child in language the child can understand the
nature of horses and the risks of handling and riding
them. r signature on the release may not operate to
excuse the stables, but it would still be evidence that
the child read and had the warnings explained to him.
That would, in turn, be important in assessing the
child's negligence or assumption of risk by conduct.
Dealing with Parents. Every injury
to a minor child creates at least three possible claims:
(1) by the child for the injuries (2) by the child's
mother for loss of the child's services and for
reimbursement of medical expenditures made by the mother
on behalf of the child, and(3) by the child's father for
loss of services and medical expense reimbursement.
A release signed by a mother or father may prevent
only the person who signed the release from suing for
injuries to the child, and may not prevent the child or
other parent from suing for those injuries. Rogers v.
Donelson-Hermitage Chamber of Commerce, 807 S.W.2d 242
(Tenn.App. 1990)(release signed by mother did not
prevent father from suing for death of minor child).
A release signed by the minor child, her mother, and
her father will at most prevent a successful lawsuit by
the mother and father, but probably will not prevent the
child's suit for his or her own injuries. Nothing can
prevent that because the child cannot sign a binding
agreement not to sue and parents in most states cannot
sign away the child's rights.
Nevertheless, the warnings that accompany the release
are important even when the riding student is a minor
child and it is important that those warnings be given
to a parent as well as the child. While it is unlikely
that a release under those circumstances will prevent a
lawsuit, the warnings will become very important in
assessing fault for the accident should a lawsuit be
filed. Bulkin v. Camp Nockamixon, 79 A.2d 234 (Penn.
1951)(permitting 10 year old camper to ride over
mother's expressed disapproval was negligent).
Getting Medical Treatment for Injuries.
If a minor child is injured in a horse accident while at
your stable, you will want to obtain effective emergency
medical attention. Whether you present the child to an
emergency room or call an ambulance to transport the
child, the hospital will have two concerns: (1) consent
to treatment and (2) financial responsibility.
Without consent of a parent or guardian, many medical
procedures that might be employed in the emergency
treatment of a minor child for a horse-related accident
would be" batteries," which could give rise to a
lawsuit. The child is incapable legally of giving
effective consent to the medical procedures. In the eyes
of the law the procedures are conducted without consent
and are, therefore, batteries.
Also, while a child might be able to enter into a
binding contract for medical attention that is a
necessary, most hospitals would be reluctant to enter
into such a contract with a minor without evidence of
her ability to pay. In short, the hospital wants
evidence of health insurance before it treats the child.
Both parental consent to treatment and evidence of
insurance can be put into the same form. Once the form
is signed and notarized, it should be placed in a
three-hole binder with other medical consent forms. If a
child is injured, in the emergency of the moment one has
only to grab the entire binder and does not have to look
through individual files for the particular consent form
for the injured child.
The following form would be legally sufficient in
most states:
CONSENT TO EMERGENCY MEDICAL, DENTAL, OR
SURGICAL TREATMENT FOR MINOR CHILD
My name is _____________________. I am the
(mother)(father)(guardian) of ___________________, a
minor
child and a riding student at
________________________________________________________.
I hereby consent to any medical, dental or surgical
treatment or procedure of an emergency nature that is
reasonably necessary to save the life of the minor child
named above or to restore the child to health.
Name of Insurance Company____________________
Policy Number________________________________
I understand that should medical emergency treatment
be
required, the current insurance information listed here
will
be provided to the attending clinic or hospital to cover
future payment of incurred bills.
Emergency Phone Numbers:
Phone Number / Person to Contact
___________ ____________________________
___________ ____________________________
___________ ____________________________
___________ ____________________________
___________ ____________________________
___________ ____________________________
(signed) ____________________ (date)____________
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this ___ day
of____________, 19___.
________________________________
Notary Public in and for the State of ___________.
My Commission Expires:_________________.
The form should be signed in the presence of an
employee who is a notary public and who witnesses the
signature by signing the form and affixing the notary
seal to it. Inmost states, becoming a notary is easy and
inexpensive so there is no reason why each stable
shouldn't have at least one on the premises.
In addition to the important purpose of
identifyinginsurance information and persons to notify,
having the parent fill out that information is powerful
evidence that the form was read before it was signed.
"Reprinted with
permission of the copyright holder and the American
Association for Horsemanship Safety, Inc, P.O. Box 39,
Fentress, TX 78622."
|